| Bob Riley | 178* | 1st XI | Isham | Friendly | Away | 9 Aug 1975 | View |
| Andy Jones | 166* | 2nd XI | Whetstone 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 17 June 2017 | View |
| Steve Brooks | 165 | Fr. XI | Leicester Teachers | Friendly | Away | 6 May 2007 | View |
| Paul Dunkley | 164 | 2nd XI | Fleckney Village 2nd XI | League | Away | 18 July 1998 | |
| Laurence Perry | 157* | Fr. XI | Loughborough Outwoods | Friendly | Away | 22 June 2008 | View |
| Jason Helmn | 157 | Fr. XI | Barrow Town Fr. XI | Friendly | Away | 4 July 2015 | View |
| Karan Chandu | 155* | 2nd XI | Dunton Bassett 2nd XI | League | Away | 11 May 2019 | View |
| Paul Newnham | 153* | 2nd XI | Houghton & Thurnby 4th XI | League | Meadows | 8 Aug 2015 | View |
| Steve Brooks | 148 | 2nd XI | Bharat Sports 2nd XI | League | Away | 13 May 2006 | View |
| David Clowes | 147* | 2nd XI | Pytchlie | Friendly | Magna Rd | 14 Aug 1983 | |
| Steve Brooks | 147* | Fr. XI | Leicester Teachers | Friendly | Away | 3 May 2009 | View |
| Andy Jones | 145 | 2nd XI | Whetstone 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 18 May 2019 | View |
| Norman James | 144* | 1st XI | Stoughton & Thurnby | Friendly | Away | 9 May 1970 | |
| Michael Dunkley | 140* | 1st XI | Asian Sports 3rd XI | League | Away | 16 Sept 2023 | View |
| Bob Riley | 140* | 1st XI | Barnack | Friendly | | 21 Sept 1986 | |
| Bob Riley | 140 | 1st XI | Barnack | Friendly | Away | 18 Sept 1983 | |
| Rob Hensman | 138* | 1st XI | Langtons | Friendly | Away | 30 April 1995 | |
| Steve Brooks | 138* | 1st XI | Rothley Park 2nd XI | League | Away | 22 Aug 2020 | View |
| Andy Jones | 137 | 2nd XI | Wakerley & Barrowden 1st XI | League | Meadows | 8 July 2017 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 135* | 1st XI | Quorn | League | Home | 26 Aug 1995 | |
| Michael Dunkley | 135* | 1st XI | Leicester Banks 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 10 July 2021 | View |
| Paul Newnham | 132 | 2nd XI | Coalville Town 2nd XI | Friendly | Away | 15 July 1990 | |
| Howard Riley | 131 | 1st XI | Melton Town | Friendly | Magna Rd | 17 Sept 1978 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 128* | 1st XI | Great Glen | Friendly | Away | 14 Aug 1983 | View |
| Bob Riley | 128 | 2nd XI | Shepshed 2nd XI | Friendly | | 25 Aug 1980 | |
| Norman James | 126 | 1st XI | Kirby Muxloe | Friendly | Willow Pk | 3 July 1965 | View |
| Steve Brooks | 126 | 1st XI | Sapcote | Cup | Away | 28 June 2009 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 124 | 1st XI | Electricity Sports | Friendly | Away | 6 Aug 1995 | |
| Jason Helmn | 123* | 1st XI | Countesthorpe 2nd XI | League | Away | 9 June 2018 | View |
| Paul Newnham | 122 | 2nd XI | Rolls Royce | Friendly | Magna Rd | 22 July 1990 | |
| Bob Riley | 119 | 2nd XI | Isham 2nd XI | Friendly | Magna Rd | 10 Sept 1977 | |
| Stewart Standley | 119 | 1st XI | Carlton Hayes | Friendly | Away | 6 Sept 1981 | |
| Jason Helmn | 118* | 1st XI | Burbage | League | Meadows | 7 Aug 2004 | |
| Andy Wright | 118* | 2nd XI | Gracedieu Park 2nd XI | Cup | Magna Rd | 15 June 1987 | |
| Jimmy Young | 118* | 2nd XI | Mountsorrel Castle 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 1 Aug 1998 | |
| Michael Dunkley | 118 | 1st XI | Kibworth 4th XI | League | Away | 12 Sept 2015 | View |
| Stephen Dunkley | 118 | 2nd XI | Sharnford 2nd XI | League | Away | 8 July 2006 | View |
| Faizal Kassam | 117 | 1st XI | Leicester Ivanhoe 3rd XI | League | Away | 5 June 2010 | View |
| Dave Dunkley | 117 | 2nd XI | Isham 2nd XI | Friendly | Away | 6 Sept 1975 | |
| Paul Jones | 117 | 2nd XI | Appleby Magna 2nd XI | Friendly | | 28 Aug 1994 | |
| R.Sommerville | 116* | 2nd XI | Great Glen 2nd XI | League | Wigston RFC | 23 July 1994 | |
| Brian Hyde | 115* | 1st XI | Buckminster | Friendly | Away | 26 Aug 1991 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 115* | 1st XI | Soar Valley Records | League | Meadows | 17 July 1999 | |
| Jason Helmn | 115* | Fr. XI | Rushton | Friendly | Meadows | 27 July 1997 | |
| Ron Elliott | 114* | 1st XI | Arley Colliery | Friendly | Away | 21 July 1934 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 114* | 1st XI | Broughton Astley | League | Wigston RFC | 9 June 1990 | |
| Paul Newnham | 114* | 2nd XI | Gracedieu Park | Friendly | | 12 Aug 1990 | |
| Bob Riley | 114 | 1st XI | Rushton | Friendly | Away | 22 July 1990 | |
| Jason Helmn | 113* | 1st XI | Burton on the Wolds | League | Meadows | 18 Aug 2001 | |
| Rob Kenney | 113* | 2nd XI | Broughton Astley 2nd XI | League | Away | 3 July 2010 | View |
| Tom Ashton | 113* | Fr. XI | Loughborough Carillion O.B.
| Friendly | Away | 29 May 2011 | View |
| Paul Newnham | 113 | 1st XI | Bharat Sports | League | Meadows | 21 May 2011 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 113 | 1st XI | Rothley Park | League | Wigston RFC | 27 May 1995 | |
| Ray Morris | 113 | 2nd XI | Glenfrith Hospital | Friendly | Magna Rd | 23 July 1983 | |
| Lee Creedon | 113 | 2nd XI | Leicester Ivanhoe 2nd XI | League | Away | 14 July 2001 | |
| Ravi Savjani | 112* | Fr. XI | Fleckney Village | Friendly | Away | 29 July 2012 | View |
| Bob Riley | 112 | 1st XI | Great Glen | League | Wigston RFC | 27 May 1989 | View |
| Richard Pell | 111* | 1st XI | Fisons | League | Away | 14 June 1986 | |
| Jason Helmn | 111* | 1st XI | G.E.C. (Whetstone)
| League | Meadows | 15 June 1996 | |
| Paul Newnham | 111* | 1st XI | Leicester Caribbean | Cup | Away | 6 Sept 2009 | View |
| Andy Jones | 111* | 2nd XI | Great Glen | League | Away | 28 July 2018 | View |
| Bob Riley | 111 | 1st XI | Billesdon | Friendly | Magna Rd | 20 May 1978 | |
| Bob Riley | 111 | 1st XI | Barrow Town | Friendly | Away | 25 July 1981 | |
| Brian Hyde | 110* | 2nd XI | Barkby 2nd XI | League | Wigston RFC | 25 June 1994 | |
| Laurence Perry | 110* | Fr. XI | Fleckney Village | Friendly | Away | 28 July 2013 | View |
| Bob Riley | 110 | 1st XI | Leicester Globetrotters | League | Wigston RFC | 6 May 1989 | View |
| John Shotton | 109 | 2nd XI | Pilgrims 2nd XI | Friendly | Willow Pk | 24 July 1976 | |
| Andy Wright | 109 | 2nd XI | Leicester Taverners | Friendly | | 24 Aug 1986 | |
| Bob Riley | 108* | 1st XI | Lullington Park | Friendly | Away | 23 June 1979 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 108 | 1st XI | Great Glen | League | Away | 26 June 1993 | |
| Graham Lowe | 107* | 1st XI | Oakham | Friendly | | 16 June 1991 | |
| Ron Franklin | 107 | 1st XI | Chilprufe | Friendly | Willow Pk | 22 May 1948 | View |
| Dave Coley | 107 | 2nd XI | Littleover R.B.L. | Friendly | Away | 3 May 1987 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 106* | 1st XI | Newtown Linford | Friendly | Magna Rd | 20 Sept 1986 | |
| Jason Helmn | 106* | 1st XI | Langtons | Friendly | Away | 27 April 1996 | |
| Jason Helmn | 106* | 1st XI | Thornton St Peters | League | Away | 2 June 2001 | |
| Don Herbert | 106 | 1st XI | Leicester Banks | Friendly | Away | 25 Aug 1934 | |
| Bev Horne | 106 | 1st XI | Gracedieu Park | League | Magna Rd | 30 June 1984 | View |
| Paul Newnham | 106 | 1st XI | Langtons 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 21 May 2016 | View |
| Neel Ammanath | 106 | 1st XI | Bitteswell | League | Away | 4 Aug 2018 | View |
| Ian Riley | 106 | 2nd XI | Barkby 2nd XI | League | Away | 23 May 1993 | |
| Nitesh Chavda | 106 | 2nd XI | Dunton Bassett 2nd XI | League | Away | 16 June 2018 | View |
| Jason Helmn | 106 | Fr. XI | Kibworth | Friendly | | 5 July 1998 | |
| Bill Dalby | 105* | 1st XI | Egerton Park | Friendly | Away | 8 Sept 1934 | |
| Chris Hearne | 105* | 1st XI | Alstom (Whetstone) | League | Meadows | 12 Aug 2000 | |
| Malcolm Moore | 105 | 1st XI | Fleckney | Friendly | Away | 26 Sept 1964 | View |
| Bob Riley | 105 | 1st XI | East Haddon | Friendly | Away | 21 Aug 1982 | |
| Bob Riley | 105 | 1st XI | Great Easton | Friendly | Magna Rd | 1 Sept 1985 | View |
| Nigel Napier | 105 | 2nd XI | Quorn 2nd XI | League | Wigston RFC | 1 May 1993 | |
| Bob Riley | 105 | 2nd XI | Leicester Ivanhoe 2nd XI | League | Away | 10 Aug 1996 | |
| Jason Helmn | 105 | 1st XI | Market Overton | League | Meadows | 6 July 2019 | View |
| Andy Jones | 104* | Fr. XI | Shepshed Messengers | Friendly | Away | 18 May 2008 | View |
| Howard Riley | 104 | 1st XI | Great Glen | Friendly | Away | 30 Aug 1987 | |
| Andy Wright | 104 | 2nd XI | Medbourne | Friendly | | 10 May 1987 | |
| Bob Riley | 104 | 2nd XI | Cosby 2nd XI | League | Away | 24 July 1999 | |
| Stephen Dunkley | 104 | 2nd XI | Burbage 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 23 Aug 2003 | |
| Vaib Tyagi | 104 | 2nd XI | Anstey & Glenfield 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 15 June 2013 | View |
| Brian Lewis | 103* | 1st XI | Kirby Muxloe | Friendly | Away | 7 Sept 1969 | |
| Bev Horne | 103* | 1st XI | East Haddon | Friendly | Away | 26 Aug 1984 | |
| Graham Lowe | 103* | 1st XI | Rushton | Friendly | | 6 Aug 1989 | |
| Rob Hensman | 103* | 1st XI | Lullington Park | Friendly | Away | 23 April 1995 | View |
| Andy Wright | 103* | 2nd XI | Dunton Bassett 2nd XI | Friendly | | 21 June 1986 | |
| Michael Dunkley | 103* | 2nd XI | Gilmorton Village 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 10 July 2010 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 103* | Fr. XI | Rushton | Friendly | Meadows | 27 July 1997 | |
| Norman James | 103 | 1st XI | North Leics. Miners Welfare | Friendly | Away | 4 July 1971 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 103 | 1st XI | Queniborough | Friendly | Magna Rd | 17 Sept 1988 | View |
| Jason Helmn | 103 | 1st XI | Leicester Mossdale | Friendly | Meadows | 28 July 1996 | |
| Rob Hensman | 103 | 1st XI | Woodhouse Eaves | League | Meadows | 23 June 2001 | |
| Rob Hensman | 103 | 1st XI | Mountsorrel Castle 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 30 May 2015 | View |
| Doug Moore | 102* | 1st XI | Pilgrims | Friendly | Away | 2 Oct 1971 | |
| Jason Helmn | 102* | 1st XI | Cosby 2nd XI | League | Away | 13 Sept 2014 | View |
| Andy Jones | 102* | 2nd XI | Sileby Town 4th XI | League | Meadows | 4 May 2019 | View |
| Michael Dunkley | 102* | 1st XI | Quorn | Friendly | Away | 19 Sept 2020 | View |
| Stewart Standley | 102 | 1st XI | Kirby Muxloe | Friendly | Away | 30 June 1979 | |
| Graham Lowe | 102 | 1st XI | Talbot Sports | Friendly | Away | 20 May 1990 | |
| Doug Moore | 102 | 2nd XI | Ratby Town 2nd XI | League | Magna Rd | 9 July 1988 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 102 | 2nd XI | Huncote 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 10 May 2003 | View |
| Liam Hearne | 102 | 2nd XI | Hinckley 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 2 May 2009 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 101* | 1st XI | Broughton Astley | League | Away | 1 June 1991 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 101* | 1st XI | Stoughton & Thurnby | League | Away | 26 June 1999 | |
| Rob Hensman | 101* | 1st XI | Alstom (Whetstone) | League | Meadows | 12 Aug 2000 | |
| Jason Helmn | 101* | 1st XI | Twycross | League | Away | 20 June 2009 | View |
| Howard Riley | 101* | 2nd XI | Cosby 2nd XI | League | Home | 2 June 1990 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 101* | 2nd XI | Rothley Park 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 29 Aug 1998 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 101* | 2nd XI | Cosby 2nd XI | League | Away | 6 May 2000 | |
| Steve Brooks | 101* | 2nd XI | Stoke Golding 2nd XI | League | Away | 20 Aug 2005 | View |
| Chris Hearne | 101* | 1st XI | Birstall Village 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 14 Sept 2013 | View |
| Howard Riley | 101 | 1st XI | Bitteswell | Friendly | Magna Rd | 4 June 1977 | |
| Bob Riley | 101 | 1st XI | Ufford Park | Friendly | Away | 15 Sept 1984 | |
| Brian Hyde | 101 | 1st XI | Buckminster | Friendly | Away | 27 Aug 1990 | |
| Stewart Standley | 101 | 1st XI | East Haddon | Friendly | Magna Rd | 22 Aug 1991 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 101 | 2nd XI | Ratby Town 2nd XI | League | Meadows | 15 Aug 1998 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 100* | 1st XI | East Haddon | Friendly | Away | 11 July 1976 | View |
| Howard Riley | 100* | 1st XI | Huncote | Friendly | Magna Rd | 4 June 1978 | |
| Bob Riley | 100* | 1st XI | Kirby Muxloe | Cup | Away | 29 Aug 1981 | |
| Paul Dunkley | 100* | 1st XI | East Haddon | Friendly | Magna Rd | 20 July 1986 | |
| Graham Lowe | 100* | 1st XI | Thorpe Arnold | Friendly | | 6 June 1993 | |
| Jason Helmn | 100* | 1st XI | Shepshed Messengers | Friendly | Away | 30 July 1995 | |
| Rob Hensman | 100* | 1st XI | Rushton | Friendly | Away | 7 July 1996 | |
| Rob Hensman | 100* | 1st XI | Twycross | League | Away | 20 June 2009 | View |
| Andy Sharpe | 100* | 2nd XI | Hallaton | Friendly | Away | 1 June 1986 | |
| Kevin Commons | 100* | 2nd XI | Quorn 2nd XI | League | Wigston RFC | 1 May 1993 | |
| Bob Riley | 100 | 1st XI | Dunton Bassett | Friendly | | 6 Sept 1986 | |
| Bob Riley | 100 | 1st XI | Leicester Ivanhoe | Friendly | Away | 1st Oct 1988 | View |
| Rob Hensman | 100 | 1st XI | Cosby | Friendly | | 16 Aug 1997 | |
