| Vic Clayton | 1st XI | South Wigston School Staff | Friendly | WIllow Pk | 24 July 1952 | View |
| A.Herbert | 1st XI | I.C.I | Friendly | Willow Pk | 20 June 1956 | |
| David Hill | 1st XI | Fleckney | Friendly | Away | 23 May 1959 | View |
| David Hill | 1st XI | Weetabix | Friendly | Away | 15 May 1960 | View |
| David Hill | 1st XI | Belgrave St. Peters | Friendly | Willow Pk | 2 June 1962 | |
| David Hill | 1st XI | Houghton on the Hill | Friendly | Away | 28 May 1963 | |
| Roy Mason | 2nd XI | B.U. Sports 2nd XI | Friendly | Willow Pk | 13 May 1967 | |
| Keith Smith | 2nd XI | Victoria Road Church | Friendly | Willow Pk | 3 June 1967 | |
| Geoff Dunkley | 1st XI | Great Bowden | Friendly | Willow Pk | 29 June 1968 | |
| Roy Mason | 1st XI | Blaby Village | Friendly | Away | 28 July 1968 | View |
| Vic Clayton | 2nd XI | Hallaton | Friendly | Willow Pk | 11 Aug 1968 | |
| Nick May | 2nd XI | Kirby Muxloe 2nd XI | Friendly | Away | 24 Aug 1968 | View |
| Nick May | 1st XI | Heather Sparkenhoe | Friendly | Away | 15 Sept 1968 | |
| Keith Pyne | 2nd XI | Birstall 2nd XI | Friendly | Away | 24 May 1969 | |
| Keith Smith | 1st XI | Kirby Muxloe | Friendly | Willow Pk | 3 Aug 1969 | View |
| Roy Mason | 1st XI | Exton Park | Friendly | Away | 20 June 1970 | View |
| Brian Carter | 1st XI | Ufford Park | Friendly | Away | 11 July 1971 | View |
| Paul Bell | 1st XI | Symingtons | Friendly | Willow Pk | 20 May 1972 | |
| Roy Mason | 1st XI | Great Bowden | Friendly | Willow Pk | 16 Sept 1973 | |
| Paul Clayton | 1st XI | Thornton St. Peters | Friendly | Away | 6 July 1975 | View |
| Geoff Dunkley | 2nd XI | Barnack 2nd XI | Friendly | Away | 10 Aug 1975 | View |
| John Barlow | 1st XI | Loughborough Brush Sports | Friendly | Away | 31 Aug 1975 | View |
| Bob Riley | 1st XI | Rowland United | Friendly | Away | 23 July 1977 | |
| David Hill | 2nd XI | Great Glen 2nd XI | Friendly | | 5 May 1979 | |
| David Hill | 1st XI | Isham | Friendly | | 8 Sept 1979 | |
| Paul Ashton | 1st XI | Great Glen | Friendly | | 10 May 1980 | |
| John Hammond | 2nd XI | Norton & Gaulby 2nd XI | Friendly | | 5 July 1980 | |
| Martin Riley | 2nd XI | Medbourne | Friendly | | 17 July 1983 | |
| David Hill | 2nd XI | Glenfrith Hospital | Friendly | Magna Rd | 23 July 1983 | |
| Paul Bell | 2nd XI | Leicester Ivanhoe 2nd XI | League | Away | 29 June 1991 | View |
| Ravi Fulbaria | 1st XI | Billesdon | Cup | Meadows | 21 June 2016 | View |
| Ben Ashton | 1st XI | Market Overton | League | Away | 12 Aug 2017 | View |
| Michael Dunkley | 1st XI | Kibworth 3rd XI | League | Away | 26 Sept 2017 | View |
